Once we got to the bedroom, we both stood in front of the bed and I took his hands. Then I looked right into his eyes and he looked right into mine as well.
"Before we make love for the first time time post brother and sister with benefits, I wanna say something," I said.
"I'm all ears sis," Don replied.
Then I kissed him once and wrapped my arms around him.
"First, are you mad?" I asked.
"No sis," Don replied.
"Good, I'm still sorry, but I could have just done it at a far worse time though. I just love you probably more than life itself, and it happened as we were making love. We made love over and over again, but even still, even if we just made love once, I think I still would have eventually fell head over heels in love with you. So right now I don't wanna talk about what we are exactly, but I will after we make love for the first time after being brother and sister with benefits," I said.
"Fair enough sis," Don replied.
"But I wanna know this right now though," I said.
"Name it," Don replied.
"Were you telling me the truth when you told me you'd love me like this forever?" I asked.
He just looked into my eyes for a minute and then gave me the biggest kiss ever.
"Of course I was sis, I love you forever," Don replied.
"Then undress yourself, undress me and make sweet love to me," I said.
"Can and will do sis," Don replied.
Then he very quickly undressed himself, it only took about 10 seconds. Then as he was completely naked, he slowly grabbed onto my shirt and pulled it off me. Then he leaned his head down and moved my bra a little and began sucking on her right nipple. I immediately let out a couple moans and my panties got very wet.
"Holy shit, now that's what I like," I said.
"And just how far did it get with you two?" Don asked.
"He just pulled it out and was about to put a condom on even though I'm on the pill," I replied.
"What a gentleman," Don said.
"Smart ass, but as he took the condom and was about to open it, I guess it became real, it was gonna happen unless I stopped it right there, I couldn't do it. I couldn't have another guys cock inside me," I replied.
"I can't say I completely understand, but I love that you made that decision though," Don said.
"Me too, now enough talking, I want you inside me now," I replied.
Then he got down on his knees and undid my pants. He pulled them to the floor and kissed my stomach once. He very quickly pulled down my underwear and stood back up.
"Last, but not least, my favorite," Don said.
"Did you quote Jim Carrey from The Mask?" I asked.
"Would it turn you on if I did?" Don asked as he took my bra off.
"Well, we're already naked, I don't think it'll be a problem," I replied.
Then I laid down on the bed and he got on top of me. We made out passionately for a minute and wrapped our arms around each other, but he had stuck it in there just yet.
"Don't you wanna make love?" I asked.
"Yes, how nuts is it driving you?" Don asked.
"Extremely nuts, now Don, I want it inside me now, so stick it in and make love to your sister," I replied.
"Yes sis," Don said.
Then he actually stuck his cock inside me.
"You are the worst Don, I fucking love and hate you at the same time so damn much. Why must you torchure me?" I asked.
"Well because you are my sister and you it's funny, but you know you love me," Don replied.
"Just make it worth the wait already and pound me hard," I said.
Then as I practically begged him to do for me, he began pounding me hard. He had his entire cock inside me for a minute and began thrusting, but of course I knew my pussy would be sore in no time.
"Oh yes Don, make my pussy as sore as you can get it already, make it really sore. I wanna scream at the top of my lungs," I said.
I felt us together as close as we could get and my boobs were leaning against his chest and our bellies were right on each other as well. We both put our arms around each other as tightly as we could, but then he couldn't thrust as much then.
"We're just an incestuous sandwich with your boobs in he middle," Don said.
"I suppose so," I replied as I laughed a little.
Then he moved my hair a bit out of my eyes and gave me another kiss. Then we both looked into each others eyes for a few seconds.
"Would you tell me you love me already?" I asked.
"I love you sis," Don replied.
"Don;t you love it when you listen, I love you too," I said.
Then he leaned in and ave me another big kiss. We made out for about 5 minutes straight then and then I think we both knew how in love we were. We knew it before that, but still once again, as we made out passionately as we made love, it was like nothing else mattered. He juts stayed on top of me with his dick inside me, but we did break the kiss.
"If I didn't know how much I loved you, I sure know how much I love you now Tiffany," Don said.
Then I wrapped my arms around him tight, really tight and so did he.
"Well, can we have sex tomorrow night?" Don asked.
"You wanna book me in advance?" I asked.
"And the night after that, and about another a few nights after that," Don replied.
"Why?" I asked.
"I wanna sleep with my sister as much as I can," Don replied.
"Are you saying you wanna be my boyfriend?" I asked.
"Well I wanna see where it goes if that's OK," Don replied.
"I can o that for you," I said.
"Thank you sis," Don replied.
"But when you cum, I wanna see it though," I said.
"Deal," Don replied.
Then he began thrusting his a little faster once again. I let out some louder moans that time. I think I was more than turned on by the proposal I think. He wanted to officially start dating. I think as a result, I put my defenses down and I just couldn't hold it anymore.
"Holy shit Don, you are making your sister blow," I said.
Then he pulled out and got a good look at my pussy as I exploded everywhere. Of course with being right there, I got some on his face as well. Then he climbed up and shot his load onto his tits and stomach. Then of course as we always did, he cuddled with me.
"You know, you never did tell me, did Julie like to cuddle after wards?" I asked.
"And you never did tell me, are you a one lady woman?" Don asked.
Then I laughed a bit.
"Well I'll definitely run it by you if I wanna have sex with her again, but yes I think she will be the only woman I get with," I replied.
"OK then, yes she did like to cuddle after wards. I've learned that cuddling is really important to a lady. I guess it implies it wasn't just sex," Don said.
"So you were setting me up the whole time then, cuddling with me like that just getting me right where you want me, you sly dog," I replied.
"Well it worked," Don said.
"Damn right it bro. It worked all too well, especially if we wanted to just be brother and sister with benefits, maybe you were just too good to me," I replied.
"You say it like it's a bad thing," Don said.
"Hey don't be putting words in my mouth," I replied.
"Fine pain in the butt," Don said.
"You know you love me," I replied.
Then we continued to cuddle for a few more minutes. I was just thinking about what this meant though, I couldn't help but talk to him about it.
"Well, what does this make us?" I asked.
"Well boyfriend and girlfriend I guess," Don replied.
"But do you really wanna date me though?" I asked as I leaned up and looked at him.
"Well we still get to have sex whenever we want right?" Don asked.
"You mean whenever I want right?" I asked.
Then he gave me a look, so I kissed him.
"OK I'll let that slide this time, but don't be thinking you can get out of trouble just by kissing me, that shit isn't gonna fly," Don replied.
Then we both laughed and kissed him again. Then I rested my head back on his chest. A couple minutes later my phone rang.
"Oh it's the very new ex again," I said.
Then I answered the phone and leaned up as I was on the side of the bed.
"Ted and I just had sex for the first time," Julie said.
"Congratulations, it feels great doesn't it?" I asked.
"Well I don't think it was as good as we both thought it would be, but it was good though. You were right it was different being with him sense we already love each other," Julie replied.
Then I covered the speaking part and told on what was going on.
"Well are you gonna do it again?" I asked.
"We don't know yet, do you think we should?" Julie asked.
"Well personally I'd say you need to know you are both ready to go down that road, trust me there are not 1 but 2 point of no return spots. Unfortunately you can't see them coming and both of you have to come to your own in own time. Once one of you are there, they are pretty much gonna pull the other one in. We obviously can't tell you if you want it, you gotta decide for yourselves if you really want it," I replied.
I don't think they were 100% sure, but like I said, they had to know I couldn't tell them if they both wanted it or not. So I hung up and left it up to them to figure out. She didn't tell me if they just did anal or she blew him or what exactly, but I knew they'd figure it out.
"Wow, I really thought they'd like just make out for awhile and see how they liked that first before they had sex honestly, but that's them though," I said.
Then he leaned up and put his hands on my shoulders.
"Well, everyone has to walk their own way, all we can do is let them know what they can expect on their way. Other than that, all we can do is lay back and watch it. If it works for them, then great if not, well, shit happens," Don said.
"Wow you really put that in perspective," I replied.
"Well, I can do that too, I'm just good at making you love me," Don said.
Then we both laughed a little and we kissed each other.
"I love you Don, if you ever stop loving me though, there will be extreme hell to pay," I said.
"I'm forewarned Tiffany, I love you too," Don replied.
Then we kissed once again and he put his hands on my boobs. He gave them a gentle squeeze as we made out a bit.
"Damn my sister drives me crazy," Don said.
"And I'm not supposed to drive you crazy? Is that what you are getting at brother?" I asked.
Then he took my hands in his hands.
"No, I like it truth be told. I think Ted is gonna like it too, I mean just look at us now, we're in love and still having great sex. If it wasn't good, then obviously we both wouldn't be naked in the same bed now would we, but here we are. If he seriously wanted to do it and has wanted do it for awhile, then there something there. If they had sex, then obviously they both wanted it, but sometimes people are more worried about other people think then what they think. So one of them may just say they don't wanna do it because they think the other isn't that into it. So we'll see," Don said.
"I guess so, well can I sleep with you now?" I asked.
"You don't wanna have sex again?" Don asked.
Then I kissed him once.
"Well, we can have sex whenever we want, we don't have to have all the time, let's cuddle and go to sleep for now," I replied.
"OK sweetheart, I love you," Don said.
"I love you too," I replied.
Then he shut the light off and we went to sleep. That was probably the best night of sleep I think either one of us ever had. The next day was Saturday and of course we slept in, but of course we had to get up sooner or later. We got up around 11:00, I was awoken by Don kissing me. When I woke up, I played staying asleep for a minute, but when he least expected it, I quickly put my hands on his head and made out with him.
"How long did you think you could just keep kissing me?" I asked.
"Well I knew it was a run out the clock situation, so forever," Don replied.
Then we kissed again.
"Wow that was hot honestly, and I'm your mother," Nicole said.
"Whoa mom, how did you get in?" I asked as we covered up.
"Hey I got a key," Nicole replied.
"Well, what are you doing here?" Don asked.
"Well neither one of you bothered to answer your phone, so I decided to come over. I gotta say this is hot, a brother and sister sleeping together," Nicole replied.
"OK can you give us a minute mom?" Don asked.
"Sure," Nicole replied.
Then she went back into the living room and then got dressed.
"Do you think she is expecting us to tell her something?" I asked.
"I don't know," Don replied.
Then we both gave each other a hug and kiss and then we went out there to talk to our mom.
"So, what's going on?" Nicole asked.
"Well we were sleeping," Don replied.
"I know that, but I think you should break things off with Julie though, it's not fair to her," Nicole said.
Well obviously we needed to catch her up.
"We actually did break it off last night," Don said.
"Oh what happened?" Nicole asked.
"Well as you know I went on a date last night and it was with her brother Ted. I had no idea he was her brother. Anyway we were gonna do it and I couldn't do it, so we came back here and I just confessed to him, I couldn't do it anymore. I had to be with him and Julie pretty much took it from there. She said when they had sex that he was having sex with me. So she understood, and let us be together," I replied.
"OK then, well that's weird I think. But what about them though?" Nicole asked.
"I wouldn't worry about them," I replied.
"What does that mean?" Nicole asked.
"Don't worry about it. So right we're boyfriend and girlfriend, and where it goes from there, I guess we'll find out then," I replied.
Then there was a knock at the door.
"Now whose here?" I asked as I got up.
I answered the door and found Ted and Julie there.