Hi my name is Jill and I have the two best brothers you could ask for. Our parents died in a car accident some years ago when we were all teenagers. Now I'm 25, my older brother Lenny is 28 and my younger brother Carl is 23. So I'm the middle child and we all live in the house we grew up in. Over the years since then, we had all became close to each other, really close if you know what I mean. Now I'm not proud of myself, but it just happened honestly, I'm having sex with both of my brothers. Now I'm not ashamed about it being incestuous, I'm not ashamed about that at all, but what I'm ashamed of is that my brothers don't know about each other. I've been having sex with both of them on the down low. Honestly it happened with 1 on 1 night and with the other a couple weeks later.
So I've been juggling them for about a year now and they still have no idea. I know it's not fair to them at all, but I don't wanna lose either one of them. I just know if I end it with 1, I'll have to end it with both of them and I don't wanna do that. The sex with them has been beyond wonderful. I can only imagine what the sex would be like if I did both of them at the same time. One of them would be on his back with me on top with my boobs up and the other one on top of me as they both have their dicks inside me. I have masturbated thinking about that hundreds of times. Anyway one Saturday night, it all came to a halt, I was having sex with Lenny missionary position when all the sudden Carl came in his bedroom and caught us.
"What the fuck are you doing sis?" Carl asked.
We both looked over at him, but only one of us knew why he was looked so pissed off.
"So, you are with him now?" Carl asked.
Of course Lenny thought that was weird.
"What do mean 'with him now'?" Lenny asked.
I was busted, there was going denying it then. Call it whatever you want, but I wasn't gonna lose both of them without a fight, so I broke out a few tears.
"I'm sorry Carl, and I'm sorry to you too Lenny, I've been having sex with both of you about a year now," I said in tearful tone.
It wasn't quite winning them over just yet, they were both giving me horrible looks, so I began crying.
"Don't look at me like that, I've been closer than ever to both of you. You both love me more than anything else in the world," I said.
Then Lenny got off me and stood up. He covered up and they both gave me bad looks as I really broke out the tears. That was definitely their weak spots, or so I thought. They just looked at me with their dirty looks, obviously I wasn't about to change their minds.
"Can the waterworks already," They both said.
Well, I felt I had to say something.
"I'm sorry, I didn't wanna lose you two, you both mean everything to me. I've felt so many connections to both of you. Now that you know about each other, what now?" I asked.
They both looked at each other for a minute and I had no idea what was going through their heads.
"I think we're done sis, I'm sorry but this is bullshit, how could you think you could just juggle us like that?" Lenny asked.
"I don't know," I replied.
The tears tugged at their heart strings, but just not enough I guess. They both just left the room and went to their own rooms. Of course I immediately got up and tried to talking to them, but they wouldn't talk to me. I went to bed in more tears than I think I ever shed in my life. That night I didn't sleep a wink. The next morning I got up and they were both doing their normal Sunday morning things, eating breakfast, watching TV and everything else. I tried talking to them again though.
"Can we please talk about this?" I asked them both.
"No, let's just move passed this sis. We had amazing sex, but I'm not sharing you and he's not either. Simple as that, let's not drag this out further than we need to," Lenny replied.
"So we're just gonna pretend this never happened?" I asked.
"Yes, in a nutshell, there is no reason to get into all the details," Carl replied.
So they still weren't budging, and over the next few weeks they still wouldn't talk to me about it. They weren't making me feel like shit, I was doing that all on my own. I couldn't help it, I had the two best relationships ever and in one minute, they both ended. So eventually I just gave up, and the worst part about the whole thing, I couldn't blame them. I had been juggling them both and broke their hearts, but about a month after that night, things finally changed. They both came into my bedroom as I was just laying there doing nothing.
"What are you two doing in here?" I asked.
They both gave me kisses on my forehead.
"We still love you sis," Lenny said.
"I know that," I replied.
They both gave me a hug and laid down with me.
"Sis, we're sorry. We know you didn't plan it that way," Carl said.
"I know, but why wouldn't you talk to me about this?" I asked.
"We admit, it was a dick move on our part, but we wanna do something to make it up to you though," Lenny replied.
"What do you mean?" I asked.
Then Lenny kissed me passionately for a minute, and then Carl kissed me passionately as well.
"We do love you sis, now let us both make love to you to prove it,," Carl said.
Carl and I made out for a minute as Lenny got down on his knees on the floor. Lenny unbuttoned my pants and pulled them down. Lenny lifted up my shirt with his left hand and my boobs made an appearance. I took it off completely as Lenny pulled my panties off. Carl took off my bra and then I was completely naked, I just knew at the back of my mind that this was too good to be true, but yet it was happening. Lenny got back on the bed with us and Carl let me kiss him as well. I went back and fourth for a minute and Lenny put his hand on my pussy. Of course it was already really wet, but then it was soaked. He rubbed it slowly for a minute, then I wanted them naked as well.
"Well, you can't make love to me not being naked, got out of those clothes now," I said.
They had no problem with that, so they really loved me to do this for me. They both got naked in about 20 seconds and Lenny sat next to me for a minute, then Carl took my hand and helped me up. I got right in front of Lenny. Both of their cocks were very hard, then all of the sudden, I felt Carl's very hard cock go up inside my pussy.
"Holy shit," I said.
I leaned down and took Lenny's cock into my mouth. Both guys let out a large moan right then. I sucked on Lenny's cock really passionately as Carl began thrusting his cock in and out of my pussy. I was finally having sex with both of my brothers, whether this was a one time thing or not, I was enjoying myself.
"Holy shit sis that feels so damn good," Lenny said.
I know I was a good dick sucker, but they made it seem like I was a blow job goddess. I began making slurping as I sucked on Lenny's cock really quickly. I was going up and down probably as quickly as I could go and I think we all were loving this like nothing else. Carl was jamming his cock in my pussy like mad, his cock was about 8 inches long an thick while I was trying to put Lenny's 9 inch cock all the way into my mouth. We were already getting really sweaty and excited, but we were having a threesome.
"Oh fuck yes Carl, shove that cock into my pussy deep," I said as I moaned.
I leaned up a bit and so did Lenny. They both were right up against me, so I was in the middle of our little sandwich. My boobs pressed up against Lenny's chest and they both wrapped their arms around each other, so I was really crammed, but if I had to be cramped, I would wanna be in between them. I toyed with the idea of getting them to kiss or something, but decided not to, I didn't wanna push it. I grabbed onto Lenny's cock and stroked it slowly as I kissed him a few times, but of course I turned my neck over and kissed Carl a few times as well.
"I love you my brothers," I said.
"We know, we love you too," They both replied.
We all laughed as Carl took his cock out of me and then Lenny pushed us both down.
"What was that for?" I asked.
"I just felt like it," Lenny replied as he got on top of me and inserted his cock into my pussy as Carl inserted his cock into my asshole as well.
I immediately cracked a huge smile, my fantasy was coming true, they both had their cocks inside me at the same time. Lenny and I made out passionately for a minute as he began thrusting his cock in and out my pussy. Carl may have been at the bottom, but it was still a very pleasurable spot to be in. He couldn't thrust his cock much, but it still felt just as great in my asshole though.
"Oh my god you 2, you are making me feel so damn good, get those dicks inside me deep, really deep for me," I said.
That made it so much hotter, they both shoved their cocks inside me like mad and I was breathing in and out very heavily, they were giving to me like I never ever felt before in my life. My heart was racing and both holes down there were getting very sore all of the sudden. It was a good kind of pain of course though. I began moaning like mad as they both weren't showing any signs of showing mercy.
"Fuck yes my brothers, make your sister feel good, really good," I said.
They weren't just making me feel good, they were making me feel wonderful. Lenny put his hands on my boobs and squeezed them a bit. If there was only one thing that could make the experience any better, it would involve my boobs. My boobs were solid c-cups too, so they both drooled over them, they were like magic.
"Take our cocks sis, take them up inside you and moan for us, moan loudly, really loudly," Lenny said.
I was moaning really loudly already, but obviously they wanted me to moan even louder I guess. With both of their cocks inside me I was moaning as loudly as I could, then I began moving around like mad as well.
"Fuck yes!" I screamed.
I just couldn't hold it anymore, I just exploded all over both of their cocks.
"Oh fuck yes," I said.
They both looked down a bit and saw the floor was really wet.
"Wow sis, you must have really liked that," Lenny said.
"Just a little bit," I replied as I smiled.
"Obviously," Carl said.
We all got up, they stood up on their feet and I got on my knees. I grabbed onto their cocks, one in each hand and stroked them both very slowly.
"Seriously, absolutely no bullshit, you are the best brothers in the world," I said.
I leaned my head towards Lenny's cock and took it in my mouth. I sucked on his cock for a minute as he moaned, but of course Carl got jealous, so I sucked on his cock as well. I alternated between their cocks for a few minutes, I kept sucking on their cocks as if it was gonna be the last thing I would ever do. As I had one cock in my mouth, I stroked the other with my hand. Then a couple minutes later, I just stroked both cocks as quickly as I could. My hands were getting very tired, but I wasn't gonna stop until I had cum splashing on me from both of their cocks. Wherever their cum landed didn't matter, as long as it was somewhere on me. They both leaned their heads back and began moaning really loudly after a few minutes.
"Holy fucking shit sis!" They both screamed.
Then I made them both erupt bug time all over me. They mostly got my big boobs, but it was beyond amazing to have the two men I loved most in the world shoot their loads onto me.
"Holy shit you two, you have secret oceans in there or something?" I asked.
"Maybe we do," Carl replied.
I stood up and grabbed onto their cocks again to stroke them. I kissed them both a few times as we were all really close.
"Best sex of my life," I said.
"Well, we'll do anything for you sis," Carl replied.
"Then let's make this work, why can't it? I can have sex with both of you, haven't you ever seen Big Love?" I asked.
"You mean you date us both?" Lenny asked.
"Yes, I've had amazing sex with both of you, and I don't wanna lose either of you," I replied.
It didn't happen then anyway, but I convinced them after the 4th time we all had sex together. Until then I didn't have sex with either of them alone though. Once we became a threesome, it was paradise. I could have sex with not 1 but 2 guys that I loved more than anything. The only issue I can foresee is having a kid, how will I decide who to have one with? I don't know, but we'll cross that bridge when we get to it, until then, I love them both more than anything and the sex is beyond amazing.